GottaLaff , (edited )
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

Via Anna Bower: 1/…

NEW: Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg responds to #Trump's motion to dismiss based on alleged discovery violations.

Bragg says that the belated production of documents by SDNY "is entirely the result of defendant's own inexplicable and strategic delay..." #legal.
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24491966-peoples-mol-re-usao-production-filed

mgmarkel ,
@mgmarkel@universeodon.com avatar

@GottaLaff I'm no lawyer, but this strategic delay seems quite explicable. DJT's lawyers are so artful at gaming our criminal justice system. But what would you expect, given their boss?

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

2/ Bower:

Bragg also filed several supporting exhibits. The exhibits include an affidavit from prosecutor Chris Conroy, who provides a more detailed account and timeline of the Manhattan DA’s efforts to obtain discovery materials from federal prosecutors in SDNY.

msbellows ,
@msbellows@c.im avatar

@GottaLaff I hate this delay. I had jury selection on my calendar, even.

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

@msbellows I know, it drives me NUTS

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

3/ More via Klasfeld: (thread)

After reviewing ~31K pages of documents from SDNY, the Manhattan DA claims that Trump already has the "overwhelming majority" of them.

Fewer than "an estimated 270 documents" haven't been disclosed to the defense — and they're mostly "inculpatory.":

“Indeed, in just the last few days, the People have conducted a more thorough review of the March 13 production…” (more)

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

4/ cont’d:

“Although that review is still ongoing, the People now have good reason to believe that this production contains only limited materials relevant to the subject matter of this case and that have not previously been disclosed to defendant: fewer than an estimated 270 documents, most of which are inculpatory and corroborative of existing evidence…”

More…

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

5/ Cont’d:

“The overwhelming majority of the production is entirely immaterial, duplicative or substantially duplicative of previously disclosed materials, or cumulative of evidence concerning Michael Cohen's unrelated federal convictions that defendant has been on notice about for months. Given the limited amount of new information in the recent productions and the USAO's completion of its productions, no relief beyond the adjournment already ordered by the Court is warranted.”

timo21 ,
@timo21@mastodon.sdf.org avatar

@GottaLaff So it's the 'Anthony Weiner laptop move' all over again?

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

6/ Klasfeld cont’d:

As widely suspected, the discovery in ques appears to relate to Michael Cohen —incl phone data that SDNY declined to provide bc it was "unduly burdensome" & DA obtained his phones by consent.

"USAO did not provide DANY w data from Cohen's phones in resp to our requests. In course of USAO's productions, DANY followed up, incl on Jan 31, 2023 & February 6, 2023, to repeat our requests for data from Cohen's phones that the USAO obtained pursuant to search warrant. [...] “

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

7/ cont’d:

The USAO declined to provide that information because it would be unduly burdensome and because DANY had obtained the phones by consent."

Once again, the DA casts blame here on Team Trump's "own inexplicable and strategic delay" — not the U.S. Attorney's office for SDNY, an "independent prosecutorial" entity operating in "good faith."

pixelpusher220 ,
@pixelpusher220@dmv.community avatar

@GottaLaff inexplicable excellent use of legal sarcasm lol

GottaLaff OP ,
@GottaLaff@mastodon.social avatar

@pixelpusher220 Yeah, that got my attention too

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • test
  • worldmews
  • mews
  • All magazines