@LeviKornelsen ...Heck, thinking about it, there's a second thing this clarifies: it seemed particularly perverse that the so-called "detective" in That One Game wasn't interested in doing detective things because her character sheet was full of detective stuff. That should have stood out as shifting things away from a pure combat focus, but somehow it didn't. Her presumption of D&D as a combat game overrode even the power of the character sheet (and the urban setting of the campaign).