I like fit guys, anywhere from skinny and wiry lean to strong and somewhat padded.
Bodybuilder not so much but those guys don't look like competition pictures when they are just walking around in the world. Yes of course there is a limit to what I find attractive but I do admire the physiques even of those I think too big.
I think my subconscious interprets fit as likely to survive and active enough to want to do things, but super fit as self-centered or obsessive.